Need opinions on video quality. (images)

K

KirbyRockz

Moderator
I thought about putting this in Creative, but all it is is a video capture. It's not really anything creative. Then I was gonna put it in the 360 board... but really, it's not a H3 video moreso than it is a test video. I just went with it because it has nice graphics.

So yeah, I've been trying to find the best way to encode videos for YouTube. I've asked some people their opinions on which is better, but they're pretty much split in replies. Tell me, which one is better to you?

21u0lz.png

Video link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7g_cSn2QOc

ic1h8h.png

Video link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiN5UiGYLe4

I honestly am leaning towards the second one; but it's not really my opinion that matters but rather the opinion of those who watch the video...
 
The difference in quality between the 2 is so minimal you would not know they were separate qualities unless you were told so. IMO.
 
x2 said:
The difference in quality between the 2 is so minimal you would not know they were separate qualities unless you were told so. IMO.
Click to expand...

I guess so... just wanted to make one last attempt to see if there's any significant quality change between the two.

Fr0dus, yeah, I did that intentionally. I focused on improving the game's graphics on YT, because I haven't really seen a vid yet dedicated to the HUD. :p
 
kirbyrockz said:
Fr0dus, yeah, I did that intentionally. I focused on improving the game's graphics on YT, because I haven't really seen a vid yet dedicated to the HUD. :p
Click to expand...

Well, when you want people to compare quality why not use the same settings.
 
Thanks, aleeock. :) I think I'm gonna end up going with a mixture of the two... Xvid codec, with Sharpen settings on.

Well, when you want people to compare quality why not use the same settings.
Click to expand...
I'm wanting people to tell me which one they like better... I didn't actually ask "which one is higher quality", as each one is different in its own way. It comes down mainly to preference. :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top