.... they're both fine and good games. i liked both, played both, beat them numerous times. i think ffVII is better, but FFVIII is the horror many people made it out to be. saying it was the change from "manga/anime with "cute" characters" is not quite right. many people disliked it because ffVII was the first major ff they played. many people dislike change greatly and seven and eight were very much so in the way magic was, the SeeD type thing with money, limits, etc. i thought it was flawed with the SeeD ranking system being able to get S rank in the beginning, the weapon system where you enhanced them through collection of items was annoying, and drawing the magic. it was annoying b/c beginners don't necessarily think right and they permanently miss a summon b/c they'll forget to draw it out. and then drawing a hundred of a spell, yikes, but i did like equipping htem to enhance defense and weapons with that ability. it was just too much of a change from 7 to 8 and people really loved 7 so they had no choice but to go against it harshly. if you were a smart player though and just always went into battle with squall in critical and abused the limit break, i think it's called renzokuken, you could fly through pretty easily. seven was just a work of art. the only thing people can do is say, 'wow, how horrible graphics, look at the box hands, etc' but the materia system was great, story was awesome, haven't had that cool of a bad guy (sephiroth) since, if not ever (i was partial to kefka, the whole poison the castle thing and kicking the emperor's corpse was comical)), the gold saucer, the Weapons (meaning giant mech things), etc made the game brilliant and a classic
both playable and good, just a matter of perspective, and the ffVIII perspective, suffice to say, is in the minority by a great deal